$49.99 – $64.95
Professional-grade smart dimmer switch with ultra-reliable Clear Connect RF technology and no neutral wire required.
You want wide ecosystem compatibility
Works with HomeKit, Alexa, Google, Nest, IFTTT, SmartThings, Control4, Savant, and more
You want smart switches that work during internet outages
Uses Clear Connect RF protocol (not WiFi) - operates fully without internet, schedules continue running
You prioritize reliability over features
Gold standard reliability - works flawlessly for years, responds instantly, recovers from outages without issues
You have an older home without neutral wires
No neutral wire required - instantly compatible with all switches regardless of home age
You need traditional 3-way switch setup
Does not work as traditional 3-way - requires Pico remote to replace second switch instead
You use incompatible LED bulbs
Some LEDs refuse to dim or never fully turn off - research bulb compatibility before buying
You want switches to remember last dim level
Standard model turns on at 100% - must manually dim each time. PD-5NE-WH model has favorite setting button.
You have tight budget for many switches
At $60-70 per switch plus required Smart Bridge, significantly more expensive than Zooz or Inovelli alternatives
LED ghosting/blinking when lights should be off due to dimmer-bulb incompatibility
Lutron SupportLights turn on randomly and become unresponsive to app or physical buttons, then turn off hours later
Lutron ForumsSome dimmers stop working suddenly with no indicator lights - may require rewiring check
Lutron SupportDimmer level reporting issues - Home Assistant/Hubitat may show incorrect dim levels
Hubitat CommunityDoes not remember last dim level
widespreadCause: Design choice - standard model always turns on at 100%. PD-5NE-WH addresses this.
LED flicker and ghosting with incompatible bulbs
commonCause: Dimmer-bulb compatibility issues - need compatible LED bulbs
Expensive compared to alternatives
commonCause: $60-70 per switch vs $30-40 for competitors, plus required Smart Bridge
Requires proprietary Pico remote for 3-way
occasionalCause: Not compatible with traditional 3-way wiring - must use Pico instead of second switch
Not checking LED bulb compatibility
Bulbs may flicker, not dim properly, or never fully turn off (ghosting)
Tip: Check Lutron LED compatibility list or test bulbs before committing
Trying to use as traditional 3-way switch
Will not work - needs Pico remote for second switch location
Tip: Buy Caseta kit with Pico remote, or accept single-location control
Not meeting minimum load requirements
Dimmer may not work or turn on lights
Tip: Verify total bulb wattage meets minimum load specified by Lutron
Initial setup, Lutron app control, voice assistant integration, geofencing
All local control, Pico remotes, scheduled events (as long as bridge has power and time synced)
Lutron collects usage data through app. Clear Connect RF protocol operates locally.
Local RF protocol is privacy advantage - switches work without constant cloud connection. Internet only needed for app/voice control.
Smart Bridge supports up to 75 devices. Clear Connect RF mesh provides reliable whole-home coverage.
75 device limit per Smart Bridge. Multiple bridges can be used for larger homes.
Inovelli Blue Series Dimmer
If: Need Zigbee/Z-Wave instead of proprietary protocol
Leviton Decora Smart Dimmer
If: Want longer warranty and WiFi connectivity
Zooz ZEN77 Dimmer
If: Want affordable Z-Wave dimmer
You prioritize reliability above all else
Industry-leading reliability - works flawlessly for years with instant response and power outage recovery
You have no neutral wires in older home
No neutral required - compatible with virtually all homes regardless of age
You have many switches to replace on budget
At $60-70 each plus Smart Bridge, costs add up fast. Zooz/Inovelli are half the price.
You need traditional 3-way wiring
Requires Pico remote instead of second switch - may not suit all installations
Standard Caseta dimmers do not remember last dim level. The PD-5NE-WH model has a middle button that can be set to your favorite dim level.
Source: Lutron ForumsNot traditionally. Caseta replaces one switch; use Pico remote in place of second switch. The Pico is battery-powered and mounts on wall.
Source: Lutron SupportLED-dimmer compatibility issue. Not all LEDs work with Caseta. Check Lutron compatibility list or try different bulbs. Ghosting/blinking indicates incompatible bulb.
Source: Lutron SupportNo. Caseta dimmers do not require neutral wire, making them compatible with older homes that lack neutral at switch boxes.
Source: Lutron SupportYes. Uses Clear Connect RF (not WiFi) for local communication. All controls and schedules work without internet. Only app and voice control need internet.
Source: Lutron Support