$200 – $280
Touchscreen deadbolt with built-in WiFi. Supports HomeKit, Alexa, Google, SmartThings. 250 PIN codes. Matter-upgradeable.
Need DoorSense open/close detection
Included sensor knows if door is fully closed before auto-locking
Sleek modern design priority
Slim profile with capacitive touchscreen looks premium
Modular connectivity needs
Swap modules for WiFi, Z-Wave, Zigbee, or Matter as needs change
Want Apple Home Key
Unlock with iPhone or Apple Watch NFC - no app needed
Need reliable HomeKit
Frequent "No Response" errors and iM1 module failures reported
Want long battery with WiFi
Only 3-6 months with WiFi module vs 6-12 months Bluetooth only
Dislike buggy apps
Yale app has confusing setup and ongoing bugs
Need quick Home Key response
Some delay in NFC unlock - Schlage Encode Plus is faster
Frequently loses HomeKit connection - shows "No Response" in Home app
MacRumors ForumsiM1 HomeKit module fails causing rapid battery drain in 10 days
Apple DiscussionsHome Key stops working for family members after reset
Apple CommunityWiFi module reduces battery life to 3 months in real testing
TechHive ReviewHomeKit connectivity unreliable
commonCause: iM1 module issues and HomeKit implementation bugs
Yale app is buggy with confusing setup
widespreadCause: Poor app development and testing
Battery drains fast with WiFi module
commonCause: WiFi module power consumption higher than expected
Module adds cost to base price
commonCause: Modular design means WiFi/Matter module sold separately
Expecting WiFi included in base model
Lock is Bluetooth only - no remote access without module
Tip: Buy "Plus" model with WiFi or purchase module separately ($50+)
Not fully closing door during DoorSense calibration
Lock wont detect door position correctly
Tip: Carefully follow calibration steps with door fully latched
Adding all family members to Home Key at once
Home Key may not work for some members if setup incorrectly
Tip: Add family members one at a time, verify each works before next
Remote access, activity history sync, guest management
Keypad code entry, Bluetooth unlock, Home Key (local), auto-lock
Lock/unlock history, access codes, battery levels. Owned by Assa Abloy.
Cloud stores access history. Yale owned by Assa Abloy (also owns August). Apple Home Key keeps data local.
Tested with up to 4 devices
Modular design allows different connectivity modules. Battery 6-12 months Bluetooth, 3-6 months WiFi. DoorSense requires calibration.
HomeKit reliability issues. WiFi module drains battery. iM1 module can fail. App needs work.
Schlage Encode Plus
If: Want more reliable HomeKit/Home Key
Level Lock+
If: Want invisible smart lock
August WiFi Smart Lock
If: Want simpler retrofit installation
Want modular upgradeable lock
Only lock where you can swap connectivity modules later
Value DoorSense feature
Included door sensor prevents locking when door is open
Need rock-solid HomeKit
Known HomeKit reliability issues - Schlage is more dependable
Budget-conscious buyer
Base price plus modules adds up - consider all-in-one options
Sensor that detects if door is open or closed. Prevents auto-lock when door isnt fully shut.
Source: Yale SupportHold iPhone or Apple Watch to lock to unlock via NFC. Works even when phone battery is low.
Source: Apple SupportNo, base is Bluetooth only. Buy "Plus" model for WiFi included or add module separately.
Source: Product Specs6-12 months Bluetooth only. 3-6 months with WiFi module. Testing shows closer to 3 months with WiFi.
Source: TechHive ReviewCommon iM1 module issue. Try removing and re-adding to HomeKit, or module may need replacement.
Source: MacRumors Forums